Plaque Buildup

Jul. 6th, 2025 18:49
[syndicated profile] futilitycloset_feed

Posted by Greg Ross

For a fictional character, Sherlock Holmes has a strangely real presence in the physical world. This plaque is posted near the Reichenbach Falls in Switzerland:

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sherlock_Holmes_plaque.jpg
Image: Wikimedia Commons

This one’s on a cottage in Sussex:

sussex holmes plaque

There’s even a plaque at the spot where Holmes met Watson.

Naturalist Gilbert White, author of Natural History and Antiquities of Selborne, seems to have had an imaginary contemporary nemesis. Someone has posted this plaque on the house opposite White’s 18th-century Hampshire home:

sullivan black plaque

(Black is the opposite of white, and Sullivan is the opposite, or at least the complement, of Gilbert.)

Finally, this plaque adorns the Park Street Eye Clinic in Tauranga, New Zealand:

nz plaque

Accurate enough.

(Thanks to readers Tom Race, Brieuc de Grangechamps, and Derek Christie.)

Sunday assorted links

Jul. 6th, 2025 16:45
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

1. Not the kind of lottery winner you are looking for.  “According to court records, Farthing strangled a girlfriend; sold cocaine to an undercover police informant; escaped from a prison work detail; bribed a corrections officer to deliver Xanax and Oxycodone into a state facility; possessed stolen firearms; and even involved his mother in a marijuana smuggling plot for which they were both indicted.”

2. Fragrance design for AI?

3. On cancer vaccines.

4. Someone tries to defend mass tourism.  It is good for most of those who do it!  Yet there is a better way.

5. LLMs in evolutionary game theory.  “Google’s Gemini models proved strategically ruthless, exploiting cooperative opponents and retaliating against defectors, while OpenAI’s models remained highly cooperative, a trait that proved catastrophic in hostile environments. Anthropic’s Claude emerged as the most forgiving reciprocator, showing remarkable willingness to restore cooperation even after being exploited or successfully defecting.”

6. Poland and Germany and the border.

7. Ross D. on BBB (NYT).

8. Fairfax County a center for immigration arrests (NYT).  Boo, we are one of the last places that need this.

The post Sunday assorted links appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

This was a discussion topic at the recent and excellent Civic Future meet-up outside of London.  These were my nominations of how new religious ideas might be most likely to emergen in the near future:

1. We don’t have good models for the evolution of religious thought.  So bet on the numbers, and figure that Africa will produce new variants of Christianity and Islam.  Furthermore, many African regions have not been Christian or Muslim for very long, not by historical standards.  That might boost the chances of innovation, since to them it is not a very fixed doctrine.

2. A Constantine for China.  If China evolves in a more capitalist direction, leadership might decide that some additional ideologies are needed.  Christianity does seem to attract a reasonable number of adherents in China when it is allowed to grow.  Constantine formalized Christianity for the Roman Empire, and perhaps a future Chinese leader will create a “Christianity with Chinese characteristics” to make rule easier.  Still, I think most people there would not believe it.

3. For my low probability dark horse pick, imagine that LLMs allow us to start talking to some animals.  Some small percentage of humans might start worshipping those animals, say they are whales?  It would hardly be a first for identifying animals with the deity.  A weirder scenario yet is that those animals have gods (God?) and some humans start worshipping those gods.  As I said, a low probability scenario!  Nonetheless an intriguing idea.

The post Three scenarios for the emergence of new religious doctrine appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

BBB on drug price negotiations

Jul. 6th, 2025 04:55
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

The sweeping Republican policy bill that awaits President Trump’s signature on Friday includes a little-noticed victory for the drug industry.

The legislation allows more medications to be exempt from Medicare’s price negotiation program, which was created to lower the government’s drug spending. Now, manufacturers will be able to keep those prices higher.

The change will cut into the government’s savings from the negotiation program by nearly $5 billion over a decade, according to an estimate by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office.

…the new bill spares drugs that are approved to treat multiple rare diseases. They can still be subject to price negotiations later if they are approved for larger groups of patients, though the change delays those lower prices.

This is the most significant change to the Medicare negotiation program since it was created in 2022 by Democrats in Congress.

Here is more from the NYT.  Knowledge of detail is important in such matters, but one hopes this is the good news it appears to be.

The post BBB on drug price negotiations appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

XQuartz EGL

Jul. 5th, 2025 19:18
[syndicated profile] jwz_blog_feed

Posted by jwz

I know I am probably the last person in the world still running X11 on a Mac, but some time around macOS 14.7.3, XQuartz stopped working with OpenGL programs that use EGL instead of GLX. If someone could tell me how to fix this, that would be great:

libEGL warning: egl: failed to create dri2 screen MESA: error: Failed to attach to x11 shm MESA: error: Failed to attach to x11 shm MESA: error: Failed to attach to x11 shm ...

[syndicated profile] 70sscifiart_feed
Two artworks - the left one has an old man in a white beard with blue robes reclining on a chair against a brownish background, with his head propped up by one arm, with a skull, wizard hat, and a statue of a little fish guy next to him. The right one has another old guy with a white beard in a purple robe, reclining the same position with a similar background color, but no skull or fish guy.ALT

On the left is Richard Corben’s 1985 illustration, “Wizard’s Dreams.” On the right is Corben’s inspiration: Rembrandt’s famous 1630 painting, “Jeremiah Lamenting the Destruction of Jerusalem.”

Via this list of homages from Corben.

[syndicated profile] 70sscifiart_feed








rassilon-imprimatur:

Classic Doctor Who monsters the Voord, the Silurians, the Wirrn, and the Yeti, as reimagined by Colin Howard (I believe from the 1993 calendar, but I could be mistaken). 

Turnabout

Jul. 5th, 2025 16:42
[syndicated profile] futilitycloset_feed

Posted by Greg Ross

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Maxwell_theorem2.svg
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Draw a triangle ABC and pick a point V that’s not on one of its sides. Draw a segment from each of the triangle’s vertices through V. Now draw a new triangle whose sides are parallel to these three segments. Segments drawn from each of this new triangle’s vertices and parallel to the first triangle’s sides, as shown, will meet in a common point.

Proven by James Clerk Maxwell!

Lead! It's what lungs crave!

Jul. 5th, 2025 16:04
[syndicated profile] jwz_blog_feed

Posted by jwz

One of the disposable e-cigarettes studied released more lead during a day's use than nearly 20 packs of traditional cigarettes:

"When I first saw the lead concentrations, they were so high I thought our instrument was broken," Salazar said. [...]

"We found that these disposable devices have toxins already present in the e-liquid, or they're leaching quite extensively from their components into e-liquids and ultimately transferred to the smoke," Salazar said.

Leaded bronze alloy components in some devices leached nickel and lead to the e-liquid. Nickel was also released from heating coils, and antimony was present in unused e-liquids at high levels, both of which increase the risk of cancer.

The researchers also assessed the health risk for daily users. Vapors from three of the devices had nickel levels and two devices had antimony levels that exceeded cancer risk limits. Vapors from four of the devices had nickel and lead emissions that surpassed health-risk thresholds for illnesses besides cancer, such as neurological damage and respiratory diseases.

I'll bet Bobby Brainworms think you need a lot more lead and antimony supplements in your diet. But he's not going to state that outright, he's just asking questions...

Previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously, previously.

[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Alex Tabarrok

In an excellent interview (YouTube; Apple Podcasts, Spotify) Dwarkesh asked legendary bio-researcher George Church for the most under-hyped bio-technologies. His answer was both surprising and compelling:

What I would say is genetic counseling is underhyped.

What Church means is that gene editing is sexy but for rare diseases carrier screening is cheaper and more effective. In other words, collect data on the genes of two people and let them know if their progeny would have a high chance of having a genetic disease. Depending on when the information is made known, the prospective parents can either date someone else or take extra precautions. Genetic testing now costs on the order of a hundred dollars or less so the technology is cheap. Moreover, it’s proven.

Since the early 1980s the Jewish program Dor Yeshorim and similar efforts have screened prospective partners for Tay-Sachs and other mutations. Before screening, Tay-Sachs struck roughly 1 in 3,600 Jewish births; today births with Tay-Sachs have fallen by about 90 percent in countries that adopted screening programs. As more tests are developed they can be easily integrated into the process. In addition to Tay-Sachs, Dor Yeshorim, for example, currently tests for cystic fibrosis, Bloom syndrome, and spinal muscular atrophy among other diseases. A program in Israel reduced spinal muscular atrophy by 57%. A study for the United States found that a 176 panel test was cost-effective compared to a minimal 5 panel test as did a similar study on a 569 panel test for Australia.

A national program could offer testing for everyone at birth. The results would then be part of one’s medical record and could be optionally uploaded to dating websites. In a world where Match.com filters on hobbies and eye color, why not add genetic compatibility?

Do it for the kids.

Addendum: See also my paper on genetic insurance (blog post here).

The post Genetic Counseling is Under Hyped appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

Online dating apps have transformed the dating market, yet their broader effects remain unclear. We study Tinder’s impact on college students using its initial marketing focus on Greek organizations for identification. We show that the full-scale launch of Tinder led to a sharp, persistent increase in sexual activity, but with little corresponding impact on the formation of long-term relationships or relationship quality. Dating outcome inequality, especially among men, rose, alongside rates of sexual assault and STDs. However, despite these changes, Tinder’s introduction did not worsen students’ mental health, on average, and may have even led to improvements for female students.

That is from a new paper by Berkeren Büyükeren, Alexey Makarin, and Heyu Xiong.

The post The Impact of Dating Apps on Young Adults: Evidence From Tinder appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

Wayland registries

Jul. 5th, 2025 02:06
[syndicated profile] jwz_blog_feed

Posted by jwz

Dear Lazyweb, how do you iterate the wl_registry more than once? I have two modules that have nothing to do with each other, but need to find their respective protocols, and apparently you can't call wl_registry_add_listener more than once. The second one is ignored.

Is there any actual API documentation for this shit? I have found only the two extremes of "hex dumps of socket protocol" and "language-agnostic XML file fetishism".

Previously, previously.

What I’ve been reading

Jul. 5th, 2025 04:28
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

1. Michael Kempe, The Best of all Possible Worlds: A Life of Leibniz in Seven Pivotal Days.  A good book, I had not realized the full import of Leibniz in the history of binary computation, his understanding of “novels as models,” his theory of social distancing during epidemics, or just how much attention he devoted to the historical episode of a woman as Pope.

2. Judith Scheele, Shifting Sands: A Human History of the Sahara.  A quite good, informative, and readable book on a very much undercovered topic.  Saharan civilization is something that runs deeper, and is more coherent, than any set of national boundaries in the region.  The author spent years living in the Saharan region of Chad.  Recommended, a good example of “you should read a book about a topic you are not thinking of reading about.”

3. Frank Close, Destroyer of Worlds: The Deep History of the Nuclear Age 1895-1965.  A good look at the underlying scientific history behind nuclear, most of all in the pre-Manhattan project years.  I had not sufficiently realized how dangerous this research was, and how many of the people died prematurely from cancer, quite possibly from radiation exposure.

4. Bijan Omrani, God is an Englishman: Christianity and the Creation of England.  Some might argue this book is a “duh,” nonetheless I found it a good overview of the importance of Christianity in British history, and suggesting that those ties should not be lost or abandoned,

5. Sam Dalrymple, Shattered Lands: Five Partitions and the Making of Modern Asia.  Are you excited by the prospect of learning more about why Burma split off from the rest of the Raj in 1937?  If so, this is the book for you.  It also has good coverage on the role of the Middle East in the history of the Raj.

6. Perry Anderson, Disputing Disaster: A Sextet on the Great War.  This strikes me as the kind of book where a very established author is seeking to work out issues that preoccupied him as a much younger man.  Such books tend to be interesting but also incomplete and unsatisfying?  Overall I am glad I read this one.

7. Diana Darke, Islamesque: The Forgotten Craftsmen Who Built Europe’s Medieval Monuments.  Perhaps overargued in places, but an excellent book, with super-clear explanations and wonderful illustrations.  Excerpt: “No architectural style just ‘appears’ magically out of nowhere.  All the key innovations attributed to Romanesque — new vaulting techniques, the use of decorative frames, interlace and ornamental devices like blind arcades, Lombard bands, blind arches, lesenes, Venetian dentil and the use of fantastical beasts and foliage in sculpture — can be traced back to their origins, and all of these without exception lead us eastwards [to Islam].”

The post What I’ve been reading appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

New York facts of the day

Jul. 4th, 2025 16:02
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

It’s truly astonishing how fiscally irresponsible New York is. The state budget proposal calls for $254 billion in spending, which is 8.3 percent higher than last year. That comes despite New York’s population having peaked in 2020. It’s a spending increase far in excess of the rate of inflation to provide government services for fewer people.

Ditch compares the New York state budget to the Florida state budget, a sensible comparison since both are big states with major urban and rural areas and high levels of demographic and economic diversity. He finds:

  • New York’s spending per capita was 30 percent higher than Florida’s in 2000. It was 133 percent higher last year.
  • New York’s Medicaid spending per capita was 112 percent higher than Florida’s in 2000. It was 208 percent higher last year. Florida has not expanded Medicaid under Obamacare, while New York has expanded it more aggressively than any other state. “For perspective, in 2024 New York spent nearly as much per capita on Medicaid ($4,551) as Florida did for its entire state budget ($5,076).”
  • New York’s education spending per student is highest in the country, at about $35,000. Florida spends about $13,000 per student. Florida fourth-graders rank third in the country in reading and fourth in math. New York fourth-graders rank 36th and 46th.
  • Florida has surpassed New York in population and continues to boom.

Here is more from Dominic Pino.

The post New York facts of the day appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

God bless

Jul. 4th, 2025 13:56
[syndicated profile] urban_feed
May God give this (n.) his [blessing] to [continue] to [exist].
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

Many AI evaluations go out of their way to find hard problems.  That makes sense because you can track progress over time, and furthermore many of the world’s important problems are hard problems, such as building out advances in the biosciences.  One common approach, for instance, is to track the performance of current AI models on say International Math Olympiad problems.

I am all for those efforts, and I do not wish to cut back on them.

Still, they introduce biases in our estimates of progress. Many of those measures show that the AIs still are not solving most of the core problems, and sometimes they are not coming close.

In contrast, actual human users typically deploy AIs to help them with relatively easy problems.  They use AIs for (standard) legal advice, to help with the homework, to plot travel plans, to help modify a recipe, as a therapist or advisor, and so on.  You could say that is the actual consumption basket for LLM use, circa 2025.

It would be interesting to chart the rate of LLM progress, weighted by how people actually use them.  The simplest form of weighting would be “time spent with the LLM,” though probably a better form of weighting would be “willingness to pay for each LLM use.”

I strongly suspect we would find the following:

1. Progress over the last few years has been staggeringly high, much higher than is measured by many of the other evaluations  For everyday practical uses, current models are much better and more reliable and more versatile than what we had in late 2022, regardless of their defects in Math Olympiad problems.

2. Future progress will be much lower than expected.  A lot of the answers are so good already that they just can’t get that much better, or they will do so at a slow pace.  (If you do not think this is true now, it will be true very soon.  But in fact it is true now for the best models.)  For instance, once a correct answer has been generated, legal advice cannot improve very much, no matter how potent the LLM.

As in standard economics, consumption baskets change over time, and that can lead to different measures of progress (or in the economics context, different estimates of advances in living standards, depending on whether the ex ante or ex post bundle weights are used).  Researchers could attempt the more speculative endeavor of estimating how LLMs will be used five years from now in everyday life (which will differ from the status quo), and then track progress on that metric, using those value weights.  “How rapidly are we improving these systems on their future uses?”

This alternate consumption basket approach gives you a very different perspective on progress in AI.

Note also that the difference between the “Math Olympiad measurements of AI progress” and the “consumption basket measurements of AI progress” may iincrease over time, especiallly if the basket of everyday uses does not change radically.  The everyday uses will peak out near maximum levels of performance, but there will always be a new series of very hard problems to stump the AIs.  It will become increasingly unclear exactly how much AI progress we really are making.

The post A consumption basket approach to measuring AI progress appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

Wayland DPMS

Jul. 3rd, 2025 23:47
[syndicated profile] jwz_blog_feed

Posted by jwz

Dear Lazyweb, what is the proper way to tell Wayland, "power off the monitor, power it on again when there is activity"? AKA "xset dpms force off" or "DPMSForceLevel()".

The closest I have found is "wlr-randr --output HDMI-A-2 --off" which powers off as a side effect of disabling the monitor in RANDR... and it doesn't turn back on at activity.

Doing that in code (via "wlr-output-management-unstable-v1", which of course GNOME and KDE don't implement) takes 400+ lines. That's 399+ too many. And if the program crashes, congratulations, you get to reboot to turn your screens back on.

Wayfire lets you put a "dpms_timeout" number in its config file, but I can't make any sense of how that is implemented.

Wayland continues to fill me with amazement (pej., obs.)

Previously.

Captain Save a Ho

Jul. 3rd, 2025 20:20
[syndicated profile] urban_feed
The expression, "[Captian] [Save a Ho]," is one coined and used by sex-workers, especially strippers, to designate the man who often comes into the club and, although he buys dances and utilizes dancers' services, he is constantly trying to "save" them, although they never asked for such an intervention. His methods are always underhanded and suspicious, because he at once asks dancers, "Why are you in this business? You could so so much more. You could be somebody," while at the same time buying dance after dance and coming in night after night to enjoy their work. This type of customer is the least favorite amongst exotic dancers because his intrusive questions and [holier-than-thou] attitude is not at all welcomed by hard-working women who find it to be very condescending, patronizing, and hypocritical.

Beg Pardon

Jul. 3rd, 2025 18:27
[syndicated profile] futilitycloset_feed

Posted by Greg Ross

I think I mentioned this on the podcast at some point: One summer morning in 1815, proprietor William Butterfield opened the White Wells at Ilkley, West Yorkshire, to a sound of whirring:

All over the water and dipping into it was a lot of little creatures, all dressed in green from head to foot, none of them more than eighteen inches high, and making a chatter and jabber thoroughly unintelligible. They seemed to be taking a bath, only they bathed with all their clothes on.

Soon, however, one or two of them began to make off, bounding over the walls like squirrels. Finding they were all making ready for decamping, and wanting to have a word with them, he shouted at the top of his voice — indeed, he declared afterwards, he couldn’t find anything else to say or do — ‘Hallo there!’ Then away the whole tribe went, helter skelter, toppling and tumbling, heads over heels, heels over heads, and all the while making a noise not unlike a disturbed nest of young partridges.

That’s the account recorded by Charles C. Smith in the Folk-Lore Record of 1878. Butterfield had died in 1844, but Smith had the story from his associate John Dobson, who described the bathman as “a good sort of a man, honest, truthful, and steady, and as respectable a fellow as you could find here and there.” The fairies made no comment.

Delighted

Jul. 3rd, 2025 06:25
[syndicated profile] futilitycloset_feed

Posted by Greg Ross

Josiah Winslow’s programming language Bespoke encodes instructions into the lengths of words, producing programs that look like poetry. This one prints the phrase “Hello, World!”:

more peppermint tea?
ah yes, it's not bad
I appreciate peppermint tea
it's a refreshing beverage

but you immediately must try the gingerbread
I had it sometime, forever ago
oh, and it was so good!
made the way a gingerbread must clearly be 
baked

in fact, I've got a suggestion
I may go outside
to Marshal Mellow's Bakery
so we both receive one

Related: In the early 1980s, Frank Hayes was so vexed with the S-100 computer bus that he wrote a sea shanty about it:

(Thanks, Jeremiah.)

The new Javier Cercas book

Jul. 3rd, 2025 06:34
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

The new Cercas book is El loco de Dios en el fin del mundo. That title translates roughly as “The crazy man of God at the end of the world,” noting there are ambiguities in who that man is (Cercas? The Pope?), and whether the end of the world refers to a trip to Mongolia or the apocalypse or perhaps death.

Cercas, arguably Spain’s greatest living writer, decides to shed his purely secular perspective and accompany Pope Francis on his Mongolia visit, a country with about 1500 Catholics. Like many of Cercas’s novels, it is a mix of non-fiction and fiction, and it is also self-consciously a detective story – which truths will Cercas unlock during this journey? Most of all, he wants to know if his mother will meet her husband (Cercas’s father) when she dies.

We live in a time when an atheistic European author puts down his preoccupation with Spanish history and spends almost five hundred pages engaging with the Pope and also the possibility of God. A vibe shift if there ever was one.

Cercas reports that he came away from the trip more anti-clerical than before, but on the matter of God and the miracle of the Resurrection, I read his text as ever so ambiguous.

Do not despair, the works of Cercas usually end up translated into English in a reasonably prompt manner.

The post The new Javier Cercas book appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

Big Beautiful Bill critiques

Jul. 3rd, 2025 05:05
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Tyler Cowen

So far I am not finding them very impressive.

To be clear, there are many things — big things — I do not like about the bill.  I would sooner cut Medicare than Medicaid (that said, I do not find the idea of cutting health care spending outrageous per se).  The corporate rate ends up being too low, given the budget situation.  No taxes on tips and overtime is crazy and cannot last, given the potential to game the system, plus those are not efficient tax changes.

I strongly suspect that if I knew more of the bill’s details (e.g., what exactly is the treatment of nuclear power in the current version?), I would have more complaints yet.  I do not wish to boost taxes on solar power.  Veronique de Rugy criticizes the underlying CEA projections.

That all said, doing the budget is not easy, especially these days.  Maybe I have read fifteen or so critiques of BBB, and have not yet seen one that outlines which spending cuts we should do.  Yet comparative analysis is the essence of economics, or indeed of policy work more generally.  In that sense they have not yet produced critiques at all, just complaints.  Alternatively, the critics could outline all the tax hikes that would put the budget on a sustainable path, but I do not see them doing that either.  Again, no comparative analysis.

If you don’t want to cut health care spending, what do you want to cut?  I am willing to cut health care spending, preferring to start with richer and older people to the extent that is possible.

You can always spend more on health care and save more lives and prevent some suffering.  But what is the limiting principle here?  Simply getting angry about the fact that lower health care spending will have some bad outcomes is more a sign of a weak argument than a strong argument.  Again, a strong argument needs comparative analysis and some recognition of what is the limiting principle on health care spending.  I am not seeing that.  I am seeing anger over lower health care spending, but no endorsements of higher health care spending.  I guess we are supposed to be doing it just right, at least in terms of the level?

It is commonly noted that the depreciation provisions and corporate cuts will increase the deficit, but how many of the critics are noting they are also likely to increase gdp (but by enough to prove sustainable?)?  I write this as someone who thinks the proposed Trump corporate tax rate is too low, but I am willing to recognize the trade-offs here.

Another major point concerns AI advances.  A lot of the bill’s critics, which includes both Elon and many of the Democratic critics, think AI is going to be pretty powerful fairly soon.  That in turn will increase output, and most likely government revenue.  Somehow they completely forget about this point when complaining about the pending increase in debt and deficits.  That is just wrong.

It is fine to make a sober assessment of the risk trade-offs here, and I would say that AI does make me somewhat less nervous about future debt and deficits, though I do not think we should assume it will just bail us out automatically.  We might also overregulate AI.  But at the margin, the prospect of AI should make us more optimistic about what debt levels can be sustained.  No one is mentioning that.

It also would not hurt if critics could discuss why real and nominal interest rates still seem to be at pretty normal historical levels, albeit well above those of the ZIRP period.

Overall I am disappointed by the quality of these criticisms, even while I agree with many of their specific points.

The post Big Beautiful Bill critiques appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

Expanding Knowledge

Jul. 2nd, 2025 18:53
[syndicated profile] futilitycloset_feed

Posted by Greg Ross

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Meno_(Socrates)_drawing_29.gif
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Each side of the yellow square is 2 feet long. In the Meno, Socrates asks a slave boy how long would be the side of a square that had twice the yellow square’s area. The boy guesses first 4 feet, then 3, and finds himself at a loss.

Socrates builds a square four times the size of the yellow one, then divides each of its constituent squares in half with a diagonal. The area of the blue square is thus twice that of the yellow one, and its side has the length we’d sought.

“Some things I have said of which I am not altogether confident,” Socrates tells Meno. “But that we shall be better and braver and less helpless if we think that we ought to enquire, than we should have been if we indulged in the idle fancy that there was no knowing and no use in seeking to know what we do not know; that is a theme upon which I am ready to fight, in word and deed, to the utmost of my power.”

You MUST listen to RFC 2119

Jul. 2nd, 2025 18:58
[syndicated profile] jwz_blog_feed

Posted by jwz

Eric Bailey:

It turns out you can just pay people to do things.

I found a voice actor and hired them with the task of "Reading this very dry technical document in the most over-the-top sarcastic, passive-aggressive, condescending way possible. Like, if you think it's too much, take that feeling, ignore it, and crank things up one more notch."

Previously, previously, previously, previously.

Good Day Sir

Jul. 2nd, 2025 19:10
[syndicated profile] urban_feed
A quick and curt way to end a conversation, putting a thin polite spin on the rude abruptness.

Most uses of this phrase are referencing actor [Gene Wilder's] portrayal of Willy [Wonka] in the 1971 movie "Willy Wonka & [the Chocolate Factory]," where Wonka informs Charlie he has lost the contest because he drank the burp soda, a breach in the contract he signed. "You lose! Good day, SIR!" Wonka screams at Charlie before turning back to his desk.

Linking to an animated gif of the scene with the audio intact is a popular way to assert you are done with an argument on the internet.

pocket sand

Jul. 2nd, 2025 19:10
[syndicated profile] urban_feed
a small amount of [granulated] rock particles carried [in the pocket] of ones pants used as a criminal [diversion], similar to Mace

Wednesday assorted links

Jul. 2nd, 2025 16:01
[syndicated profile] marginal_revolution_feed

Posted by Alex Tabarrok

In India, government jobs pay far more than equivalent jobs in the private sector–so much so that the entire labor market and educational system have become grossly distorted by rent seeking to obtain these jobs. Teachers in the public sector, for example, are paid at least five times more than in the private sector. It’s not just the salary. When accounting for lifetime tenure, generous perks, and potentially remunerative possibilities for corruption, a government job’s total value can be up to 10 times that of an equivalent private sector job. (See also here).

As a result, it’s not uncommon for thousands of people to apply for every government job–a ratio far higher than in the private sector In one famous example, 2.3 million people submitted applications for 368 “office boy” positions in Uttar Pradesh. 

The consequences of this intense competition for government jobs are severe. First, as Karthik Muralildharan argues, the Indian government can’t afford to pay for all the workers it needs. India has all the laws of say the United States but about 1/5 th the number of government workers per capita leading to low state capacity. But there is a second problem which may be even more serious. Competition to obtain government jobs wastes tremendous amounts of resources and distorts the labor and educational market.

If jobs were allocated randomly, applications would be like lottery tickets with few social costs. Government jobs, however, are often allocated by exam performance. Thus, obtaining a government job requires an “investment” in exam preparation. Many young people spend years out of the workforce studying for exams that, for nearly all of them, will yield nothing. In Tamil Nadu alone, between one to two million people apply annually for government jobs, but far less than 1% are hired. Despite the long odds, the rewards are so large that applicants leave the workforce to compete. Kunal Mangal estimates that around 80% of the unemployed in Tamil Nadu are studying for government exams.

Classical rent-seeking logic predicts full dissipation: if a prize is worth a certain amount, rational individuals will collectively spend resources up to that amount attempting to win it. When the prize is a government job, the ‘spending’ is not cash, but years of a young person’s productive life. Mangal calculates that the total opportunity cost (time out of the workforce) that job applicants “spend” in Tamil Nadu is worth more than the combined lifetime salaries of the available jobs (recall jobs are worth more than salaries so this is consistent with theory). Simply put, for every ₹100 the government spends on salaries, Indian society burns ₹168 in a collective effort of rent-seeking just to decide who gets them. The winners are happy but the loss to Indian society of unemployed young, educated workers who do nothing but study for government exams is in the billions. Indeed, India spends about 3.86% of GDP on state salaries (27% of state revenues times 14.3% of GDP). If we take Mangal’s numbers from Tamil Nadu, a conservative (multiplier of 1 instead of 1.68) back of the envelope number suggests that India could be wasting on the order of 1.4% of GDP annually on rent seeking. (Multiply 3.86% of GDP by 15 (30 years at 5% discount) to get lifetime value and take .025 as annual worker turnover.) Take this with a grain of salt but regardless the number is large.

India’s most educated young people—precisely those it needs in the workforce—are devoting years of their life cramming for government exams instead of working productively. These exams cultivate no real-world skills; they are pure sorting mechanisms, not tools of human capital development. But beyond the staggering economic waste, there is a deeper, more corrosive human cost. As Rajagopalan and I have argued, India suffers from premature imitation: In this case, India is producing Western-educated youth without the economic structure to employ them. In one survey, 88% of grade 12 students preferred a government job to a private sector job. But these jobs do not and cannot exist. The result is disillusioned cohorts trained to expect a middle-class, white-collar lifestyle, convinced that only a government job can deliver it. India is thus creating large numbers of educated young people who are inevitably disillusioned–that is not a sustainable equilibrium.

Mangal valiantly proposes redesigning the exams to reduce waste, but this skirts the core issue: India’s wildly skewed public wage structure. Government salaries far exceed what is justified by GDP per capita or job requirements, distorting education, employment, and unemployment throughout the entire economy in deeply wasteful ways. The only real solution is to bring public sector pay back in line with economic fundamentals.

The post Massive Rent-Seeking in India’s Government Job Examination System appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.

Page Summary

June 2025

M T W T F S S
      1
2345678
91011 12131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30      

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags